Showing posts with label terrorism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label terrorism. Show all posts

Monday, January 10, 2011

New Year: "2010 के व्यक्ति" और "2011 में छत्तीसगढ़"

इस ब्लॉग पर पिछले साल एक नई प्रथा शुरू हुई थी: बीते वर्ष में जिस व्यक्ति ने हमारे प्रदेश (छत्तीसगढ़) को अच्छे या बुरे के लिए सबसे ज्यादा प्रभावित किया, उसे "साल के व्यक्ति" का खिताब दिया गया और आने वाले वर्ष में क्या होगा, उसकी भविष्यवाणी की गई.

(1)
2010 के व्यक्ति

२०१० के "साल के व्यक्ति" (Person of the Year) डॉक्टर विनायक सेन हैं. उनके मुकद्दमे- और सजा- ने हमारे प्रदेश को भारत का ही नहीं बल्कि सम्पूर्ण बुद्धिजीवी-दुनिया के आकर्षण का केंद्र बना दिया है. ये हमारे लिए गौरव की बात नहीं है.

उनके परिवार और केस, दोनों से मैं बहुत करीब से जुड़ा हुआ हूँ. उनका फ्लैट हमारे रायपुर के घर के ठीक सामने है. डॉक्टर सेन मेरी माँ के मेडिकल कॉलेज (वेलूर) में सीनियर थे. पढ़ाई पूरी करने के बाद, हाल में आज़ाद हुए बंगलादेश जाकर उन्होनें भारत-पाकिस्तान युद्ध (१९७१) में सबसे क्षतिग्रस्त हुए इलाकों में निशुल्क चिकित्सा-सेवा दी. कई सालों तक डॉक्टर सेन अपनी पत्नी इलेना के साथ धमतरी और बालोद क्षेत्र के आदिवासी इलाकों में गरीबों का इलाज करते रहे. गुरुर के पास आज भी उनका छोटा सा क्लीनिक है, जो लगभग बंद पड़ा है. वे मेरे पिता जी के शासनकाल में छत्तीसगढ़ मेडिकल बोर्ड के सदस्य थे: उस दौरान वे मितानिन (midwife) योजना के सूत्रधार बने, जो आज पूरे प्रदेश में ही नहीं बल्कि पूरे देश में लागू हो चुकी है. इस योजना के अंतर्गत गांवों की मितानिन को आवश्यक चिकित्सा प्रणाली- जैसे मलेरिया और दस्त का उपचार- में प्रशिक्षण देकर दूरदराज़ ग्रामीण क्षेत्रों में डॉक्टरों की कमी को बहुत हद तक पूरा किया जा रहा है.

सलवा जुडूम की आड़ में हो रहे अत्याचार- सैकड़ों गांवों से हज़ारों आदिवासियों को विस्थापित कर उन्हें अपनी इच्छा के विरुद्ध भेड़-बकरियों की तरह "कैम्पों" में रखा गया, और उनको नक्सली-समर्थक बताकर मार डाला गया (अभी कुछ ही दिन पहले बीजापुर बस्ती में एक एस.पी.ओ. ने एक आदिवासी छात्र आशीष माझी की छाती में चार गोली दागकर दिन-दहाड़े ह्त्या कर दी)- को उन्होनें पी.यू.सी.एल. के माध्यम से उजागर किया, तो उन्हें नक्सलियों का डाकिया बताकर देशद्रोह जैसे संगीन जुर्म का दोषी करार दिया.

अगर गरीबों की सेवा करना और अत्याचार के खिलाफ आवाज़ उठाना देशद्रोह है, तो ये हमारे प्रदेश- और देश- के लिए बेहद शर्म का विषय है. एक नागरिक और एक वकील होने के नाते मुझे पूरी उम्मीद है कि इस गलती को बहुत जल्दी सुधारा जाएगा.

(2)
2011 में छत्तीसगढ़

A. राजनीति:
(१) भाजपा में "आदिवासी एक्सप्रेस" चलेगी, आदिवासी मुख्यमंत्री की मांग धीरे धीरे तूल पकड़ेगी: नंदकुमार साय और बलिराम कश्यप इसके सूत्रधार होंगे; शासन के कुछ मंत्री और सांसद इसको पीछे से बल देंगे. पूरी मुहिम नाकाम सिद्ध होगी, और डॉक्टर रमन सिंह अपनी कुर्सी पर बरक़रार रहेंगे.
(२) नया प्रदेश अध्यक्ष कांग्रेस को अंततः मिलेगा. वोरा-युग अब दिग्विजय-युग में तब्दील होगा. प्रदेश सरकार के खिलाफ दबे हुए जानाक्रोश को आन्दोलन का रूप देने में कांग्रेस, विशेषकर कांग्रेस के युवाओं, की अहम् भूमिका रह सकती है.
(३) छत्तीसगढ़ स्वाभिमान मंच, छत्तीसगढ़ मुक्ति मोर्चा, कम्यूनिस्ट, गोंडवाना और बहुजन समाज पार्टी के बीच आपसी तालमेल बढ़ेगा और दोनों राष्ट्रीय दलों के विकल्प के रूप में एक सशक्त और संयुक्त तीसरा मोर्चा बनाने के प्रयास किए जाएंगे. साधन और संगठन के अभाव में इसको कम सफलता मिलेगी.
(४) मंडी के अलावा दुसरे चुनाव न होने के कारण जातिवाद और राजनीति में पैसे का दुरूपयोग कम होगा.

B. कानूनी व्यवस्था/ प्रशासन:
(१) श्री कल्लूरी के नेतृत्व में दंतेवाडा में नक्सलियों से सीधा युद्ध छेड़ा जाएगा, इसमें कई निर्दोष लोग मारे जाएंगे. राजनांदगांव, सराईपाली, बसना, सारंगढ़ और गरियाबंद के जंगलों को अपना बेस बनाकर नक्सली रायपुर की ओर अपना ध्यान केन्द्रित करेंगे. डॉ. बिनायक सेन बेगुनाह साबित होंगे.
(२) छोटे-बड़े शहरों में गुंडा-गर्दी, लूट और मार-काट बढ़ेगी. बेरोजगार युवाओं की संख्या इनमें ज्यादा रहेगी. वे गली-गली में अवैध रूप से बिक रही शराब पीकर अपने गम गलत करेंगे.
(३) भ्रष्टाचार इतना व्यापक हो जाएगा की वो सार्वजनिक जीवन का मुद्दा ही नहीं रहेगा: आरोप लगेंगे, और हमेशा की तरह "मैच-फिक्सिंग" हो जाएगी!

C. अर्थव्यवस्था:
(१) सिंचाई, उद्योग और पीने के पानी की कमी बरक़रार रहेगी. सरकार इस भीषण समस्या से निपटने में पूरी तरह विफल रहेगी.
(२) जांजगीर, रायगढ़, कोरबा और भानुप्रतापपुर के रहवासी उनके क्षेत्र में अन्धाधुन तरीके से किए जा रहे औद्योगीकरण- और उसके दुष्प्रभाव (बढ़ते तापमान, घटता पानी, प्रदूषित वायू, जबरदस्ती किया गया विस्थापन)- के खिलाफ आवाज़ उठाएंगे, लेकिन पूंजीवादियों के दबाव में आकर सरकार उसे कुचलने का प्रयास करेगी.
(३) सरकार किसानों से वादा-खिलाफी करेगी: उन्हें न बोनस मिलेगा, न मुआवजा और न ही मुफ्त बिजली. इससे- और बढ़ती महंगाई से- उनकी आर्थिक स्थिति और जर्जर होगी. तेजी से बढ़ते शहरों से सटे हुए गांवों में इसका नाजाएज फायदा भू-माफिया उठाएगी. इसमें उन्हें शासकीय मदद भी मिलेगी.

D. संस्कृति:
(१) छत्तीसगढ़ी संस्कृति की धूम अब इन्टरनेट पे मचेगी- जो बहुत जल्द ही पारंपरिक मीडिया की जगह ले लेगा. सोशल नेटवर्किंग साईट "फेसबुक" पर २५,००० छत्तीसगढ़िया दस्तक देंगे.
(२) प्रदेश में पढ़ाई का स्थर, विशेषकर उच्च शिक्षा का स्थर, गिरेगा लेकिन फीस और बढ़ेगी. छात्रों में सरकार के खिलाफ आक्रोश बढ़ेगा. सरस्वती शिशु मंदिरों और एकल विद्यालयों के माध्यम से आर.एस.एस. आदिवासी क्षेत्रों में अपनी जड़ें और गहरी करेगी.
Read More (आगे और पढ़ें)......

Thursday, April 08, 2010

NAXALISM: (N) Lessons from Chintalnar


An entire company of the Central Reserved Police Force (CRPF) was ambushed by Maoists at Chintalnar, a remote outpost situated deep in the forests of south Bastar (Dantewada): in all more than 76 (of 81) soldiers were martyred, making yesterday’s violence the greatest defeat and massacre ever that the Naxalites (as Maoists in India are more commonly known) have inflicted on India’s armed forces. The local MLA, who was barely twenty kilometers away in his hometown Sukama at the time, called to say that all modes of transportation (including his own)- bullock carts, jeeps, tractors, taxis, trolleys, trucks- are being requisitioned to transport bodies to the police camp situated at a distance of barely three kilometers (about a mile and a half).

A Tale of Two Camps
At times like this, it’s easy to pontificate, more so when one is at a fairly comfortable distance: most editorialists agree that the massacre was primarily due to “intelligence failure”. It would seem that this failure is chronic. The two biggest Maoist attacks on armed forces in the state of Chhattisgarh have taken place in the immediate proximity of police camps:
(1) At Errabore (2006), more than hundred Naxalites entered the camp premises at night and conducted a 3-hour long bloodbath on the tribal ‘refugees’ (as the then state home minister termed inmates) while the armed forces entrusted with their security had very safely locked themselves up inside the thana (police station);

(2) At Chintalnar (2010), about 1000 Naxalites, all reportedly trained members of a Maoist military unit (dalam), not only ambushed the armed forces as the latter were returning from patrol duty to the police camp and made off with their ammunitions but before doing so, they had also found ample time to systematically lay down an intricate network of landmines all around the camp perimeter. The mines, as it turned out, claimed more lives than the actual shooting as soldiers fleeing to the sanctuary of the camp stepped on- and thus triggered- them. Even the anti-mine vehicle was blown to smithereens.

It is perplexing, to say the least, that our armed forces more often than not don’t have a clue about what’s happening in their own backyards. No wonder, they are sitting ducks for the Maoists, who seem to have become, well, almost invisible (if not invincible). This cloak of invisibility, no doubt, is partly due to Fear: for the battle-ravaged tribals of Bastar, to tell on the Maoists is to invite death. And yet, if this Fear of the Maoists is to be countered & overcome, then putting the tribals under a greater Fear of the Armed Forces, as Operation Green Hunt seems to have done, cannot be the solution.

The only way to overcome Fear, I believe, is by Faith.

To put it differently, you can’t have good intelligence unless the locals tell you things they otherwise would not. Caught between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea- the Maoists on the one hand, and the paramilitary forces on the other- the tribals of south Bastar prefer to remain silent. To remedy that, it is essential for the armed forces- and for the state that sends them- to win their faith. And, frankly, there is very little proof of that happening.

What's in a name?
Late last month, some villagers from Narayanpur met me. They were afraid. According to them, several soldiers of the Border Security Force (BSF) had entered their area & were carrying out ‘combing’ operations. During one such operation, one of the soldiers stopped a passing woman. He asked her name. When she answered ‘Dukhbai’, he took out his already loaded AK-47 rifle, and shot her at pointblank range. It turns out that the soldier had been given a list of names of Naxalite-supporters to comb-out, and ‘Dukhbai’ was one of them. What the soldier didn’t- couldn’t- know is that ‘Dukhbai’ is an extremely common name among tribals. (‘Dukh’ means sad, and tribals believe that a person so named would ward-off sadness all her life.)

Intelligence failure, therefore, is not only claiming the lives of our soldiers, but also of several hundreds- if not thousands- of innocent tribals.

License to Kill
Mr. Mahendra Karma, the leader of Salwa Judum, believes that recruiting more Special Police Officers (SPOs) from among the locals would enable better intelligence gathering since the SPOs understand the people, and know the terrain. His reasoning has been adopted by the state government. In fact, one of the reasons cited for the debacle at Chintalnar is that the CRPF soldiers were not accompanied by SPOs (although at least two personnel from the state police were with them) at the time of the ambush.

With due respect, it doesn’t quite work out like that. The SPOs have, more often than not, used their ‘license to kill’ to settle personal scores, and engage in extortion. Personal motives- a grudge, an age-old family rivalry, greed- underlie most ‘fake encounters’, in which innocent persons are routinely killed, then clothed in Naxalite uniform along with other ‘incriminating’ material to justify the killings. Institutions like the Vanvasi Chetna Ashram founded by the eminent Gandhian Ms. Nirmala Deshpande, which has been working for & with tribals in remote far-off areas of Dantewada, are bulldozed when they endeavor to seek justice for them: they are branded as ‘enemies of the state’.

I am acutely aware that any criticism of the armed forces at a time like this would be construed as anti-national and pro-Naxal. That is not my intention. I sincerely believe that the only reason why the Congress failed to form its government in the state in 2003 and 2008 is because of the Naxalites, or more precisely, their active prevention of a free and fair election in Bastar, possibly at the behest of the BJP leadership. So, my dislike of the Maoists- many of who are, I believe, using violence inherent to Maoist doctrine primarily as a means to stuff their pockets with money- is both personal as well as political. They are enemies, alright, who deserve to be taken out by whatever means necessary, including an all-out war. But it must be a Just War, and more importantly, it must be Won. I intend to address both these issues.

A Just War
Even though the Naxalites entertain no such notion- in this sense, Deng’s slogan “it doesn’t matter whether the cat is black or white/ as long as it catches mice”, which heralded capitalism into communist China, is, at least in its pragmatism, ironically Maoist- the fact is that as a democratic state bound by a Constitution, we must not only subscribe to, but also rigorously enforce the ideas of jus ad bellum (when it is right to go to war) and jus in bellum (what is right in war).

There is no doubt in my mind that this is the right time to go to war with the Maoists; if we do not retaliate, and retaliate effectively, it might just be too late. But the war that we fight must be just. It must, at all costs, not involve the unnecessary, unjustifiable displacement and killings of civilians, more so when the civilians in question are innocent tribals. Those of the armed forces who are found to be guilty of this most basic human rights violation- in this case, the right of a tribal to live (as opposed to being shot dead because of her name)- should not be wrongly protected; they must be brought to book. For if they are not, then there is no way the war can be won. The tribals not only need to know which side they are on (right now, they can at best be described as ‘neutral’); they also need to believe that their side is right.

The two issues, therefore, are directly linked. For us to win the war, we must necessarily fight the just war. That is the only way we can win the Faith of the tribals.

For without this Faith, intelligence failures like Errabore and Chintalnar will continue.

Read More (आगे और पढ़ें)......

Saturday, January 02, 2010

New Year: "२००९ के व्यक्ति" और "२०१० में छत्तीसगढ़"


दो नई परम्पराएं
वैसे तो ३१ दिसम्बर और १ जनवरी ग्रेगोरियन कैलेंडर के अन्य ३६३ दिनों की तरह सिर्फ दो तारीखें है. प्राकृतिक रूप से ये दूसरे दिनों से अलग नहीं हैं: दोनों दिन सुबह सूरज उगता है, और आकाश का अपना सफ़र पूरा कर शाम को ढल जाता है; चाँद-सितारे उसकी जगह ले लेते हैं.

देखा जाए तो इन दोनों तारीखों का महत्व मात्र मानव प्रजाति तक ही सीमित है और इस प्रजाति-विशेष पर भी इनका प्रभाव केवल मानसिक होता है. फिर भी इस मानसिक प्रभाव का अपना महत्त्व है: दोनों दिनों में अतीत और भविष्य का अनोखा सम्मिश्रण है: हर साल ३१ दिसम्बर की रात को जब ठीक १२ बजता है, तब उस एक क्षण में बीते हुए साल के गुजरने और नए साल के आने से जुड़ी सैकड़ों-अनगिनत भावनाओं का एकाएक समावेश हो जाता है.

इस तथ्य को ध्यान में रखते हुए, मैं इस वर्ष से ब्लॉग पर दो नई परम्पराओं की शुरुआत कर रहा हूँ. पहली: अतीत को सलाम करते हुए, हर वर्ष उस व्यक्ति को
"साल के व्यक्ति" के खिताब से नवाज़ा जाएगा जिसने हमारे प्रदेश, छत्तीसगढ़, को सर्वाधिक प्रभावित किया है. दूसरी: आने वाले साल में क्या-क्या होगा, उसकी भविष्यवाणी (और साल के अंत में, उस भविष्यवाणी का बेबाक विश्लेषण!).

भविष्य में इन दोनों पहलूओं पर आपके सुझाव आमंत्रित रहेंगे; और उन्हें ब्लॉग पर प्रमुखता से प्रकाशित भी किया जाएगा.

(१)
२००९ के व्यक्ति
२००९ के "साल के व्यक्ति" का खिताब संयुक्त रूप से श्री नरेश डाकलिया, श्रीमती किरणमयी नायक और श्रीमती वाणी राव को दिया जाता है. इन तीनों ने अपनी-अपनी व्यक्तिगत छवि और संबंधों के कारण न केवल राजनैतिक अनुमानों को बल्कि दशकों के इतिहास को भी सर के बल पलट कर रख दिया, और राजनैतिक रूप से छत्तीसगढ़ के सबसे महत्वपूर्ण शहर, राजनांदगांव, जो की स्वयं राज्य के मुख्यमंत्री का विधान सभा क्षेत्र है, और प्रदेश के दो सबसे बड़े शहर, रायपुर और बिलासपुर, के वासियों का विशवास हासिल कर वहां के प्रथम नागरिक चुने गए.

प्रदेश के एक नेता ने हाल ही में इस ओर मेरा ध्यान आकर्षित किया कि इन तीनों में ख़ास बात यह है कि वे प्रदेश के किसी भी बड़े नेता के "पिछलग्गू" नहीं कहे जा सकते; उनका स्वयं का अस्तित्व है, अपनी खुद की पहचान है. यही वजह है कि उन्हें बरसों से सार्वजनिक जीवन में सक्रिय होने के बावजूद कभी भी किसी चुनाव में पार्टी का उम्मीदवार नहीं बनाया गया.

और जब टिकट दी गयी तो शायद यह सोचकर कि वैसे भी इन सीटों में कांग्रेस का जीतना न केवल मुश्किल है बल्कि नामुनकिन. आखिरकार, पिछले बीस सालों से कांग्रेस के उम्मीदवार रायपुर और बिलासपुर शहरों में क्रमशः ३०००० और १५००० मतों से ज्यादा के अंतर से हारते आ रहे थे; और जहाँ तक राजनांदगांव की बात है, तो यहाँ हाल ही में मुख्य मंत्री जी लगभग ४०००० वोटों से जीते हैं. मुझे लगता है कि इस बात का फायदा भी इन तीनों को मिला: एक तरफ तो सत्ता के नशे में धुत भाजपाई अति-आत्मविश्वास से ग्रसित रहे; वहीं दूसरी तरफ कांग्रेस में उनके विरोधीयों ने यह सोचकर कि वैसे भी वे हार रहे हैं, भीतरघात में ज्यादा सक्रिय रहना जरूरी महसूस नहीं किया.

इस बात से हमें तीन महत्वपूर्ण सीख मिलती है. पहली: बड़े नेताओं के आगे-पीछे घूमना इतना जरूरी नहीं है. दूसरी: जनता के बीच सक्रिय बने रहना, उनके सुख-दुःख में भागीदारी रखना, राजनीति में अधिक महत्व रखता है. तीसरी: धीरज रखना, और कभी भी अपना धैर्य न खोना, पद मिले या न मिले. राजनीति के इस दौड़ में श्री नरेश डाकलिया, श्रीमती किरणमयी नायक और श्रीमती वाणी राव ने यह साबित कर दिया कि जीत कछुए की ही होती है.

(२)
२०१० में छत्तीसगढ़
A. राजनीति:
(१) भाजपा आलाकमान में २००९ के अंत में हुए परिवर्तन का प्रभाव प्रदेश की राजनीति पर पड़ेगा तो जरूर पर प्रदेश के नेतृत्व में परिवर्तन होने की संभावना २०१० में क्षीण ही रहेंगी. श्री राजनाथ सिंह का जो डॉ. रमन सिंह को अभयदान प्राप्त था, अब वो नहीं रहेगा. इस से उन्हें विफल करने में और उनकी विफलताओं का फायदा लेने में उनके विरोधी ११ अशोक रोड में सक्रिय तो होंगे, लेकिन केंद्रीय स्थर पर कमज़ोर भाजपा अनुशासन को ज्यादा महत्त्व देते हुए, मुख्य मंत्री और उनके विरोधियों (जिनकी संख्या में इजाफा होगा), दोनों पर नकेल कसने और उनके बीच संतुलन बनाने के प्रयास में लगी रहेगी.

(२) कांग्रेस में पीढ़ी-परिवर्तन का दौर और तेज होगा. नए-नौजवान चहरों को महत्त्व दिया जाएगा; उनका चयन ऊपर से नहीं होगा, बल्कि पार्टी के युवा सदस्य सीधे चुनाव के माध्यम से करेंगे.

(३) पंचायत चुनाव में अधिकतर पदाधिकारी दुबारा निर्वाचित नहीं होंगे. ज्यादा तर पढ़े-लिखे नौजवान लोग ही चुने जायेंगे. भविष्य में पार्टी और पैसे का कम, व्यक्ति की निजी छवि और संबंधों का ज्यादा प्रभाव होगा.

(४) छत्तीसगढ़ स्वाभिमान मंच दुर्ग की राजनीति में अंततः अपना खाता खोलेगी.

B. कानूनी व्यवस्था/ प्रशासन:
(१) नक्सलवाद पर सीधा फौजी आक्रमण केंद्रीय बलों के नेतृत्व में बोला जाएगा, इसमें सफलता भी मिलेगी. केंद्र
सलवा जुडूम से समर्थन वापस लेगा, वो एक विफल प्रयोग के रूप में इतिहास के पन्नो में दफ़न हो जाएगा. मानव-अधिकार के उल्लंघनों की वारदातें बढ़ेंगी, मीडिया उन्हें उजागर करने में कमज़ोर साबित होगी, लेकिन वहां सक्रिय सामाजिक संस्थायों की बातों को केंद्र गंभीरता से लेगा. निर्दोष आदिवासी मारे जायेंगे. शहरी क्षेत्र में प्रदेश की पहली बड़ी नक्सली घटना होगी. डॉ. बिनायक सेन बेगुनाह साबित होंगे.

(२) बड़े शहरों में गुंडा-गर्दी और बढ़ेगी. बेरोजगार युवाओं की संख्या इनमें ज्यादा रहेगी.

(३) प्रशासन और हावी होगा: सूचना के अधिकार अधिनियम के तहत सूचना लेने की प्रक्रिया को और कठिन बनाया जाएगा; केंद्र द्वारा प्रशासन को और अधिक जवाबदेह बनाने के कानूनी प्रयासों का भी प्रदेश में यही अंजाम होगा; प्रशासनिक खर्चों और भ्रष्टाचार में इजाफा होगा. लेकिन इन सब के विरोध में दायर जनहित याचिकाओं की सुनवाई का कोई असर नहीं होगा.

C. अर्थव्यवस्था:
(१) पानी, सिचाई और पीने दोनों, की बेहद कमी होगी. इस से कृषि पर तो सीधा प्रभाव पड़ेगा ही, साथ-साथ बड़े शहरों में भी त्राहि मचेगी. सरकार इस भीषण समस्या से निपटने में पूरी तरह विफल रहेगी.

(२) जितने भी अब तक की खदानें (कोयला, लोहा) बड़े-बड़े उद्योगों को आबंटित करी गयी हैं, उनमे से शायद ही एक-दो ही स्टील और बिजली का उत्पात शुरू कर पाएंगी. बाकी सब प्रशासन से साथ-गाँठ करके कोयले इत्यादि की काला-बाजारी ही करते रहेंगे. इसका सीधा-सीधा नुकसान प्रदेश के युवाओं को होगा: न नए उद्योग खुलेंगे, न उन्हें रोज़गार मिलेगा.

(३) भू-माफिया के आपस के खेल में जमीनों और घरों के भाव जम के बढ़ेंगे लेकिन इनमे घर बनाने वालों और रहने वालों की कमी रहेगी. अधिकतर जमीन और घर खाली ही रहेंगे.

D. संस्कृति:
(१) छत्तीसगढ़ी फिल्मों की संख्या तो बढ़ेगी, लेकिन २००९ की सुपरहिट, मया, का कोई मुकाबला नहीं कर पायेगा. छत्तीसगढ़ी गानों की टी.वी. चैनलों और वीसीडी के माध्यम से ग्रामीण क्षेत्रों में धूम बनी रहेगी.

(२) क्षेत्रीय टी.वी. चैनलों में कर के अभाव से प्रोग्राम्मिंग का स्थर गिरेगा. केबल माफिया के केन्द्रीयकरण के प्रयासों से केबल-वार होगी, जिसका भार सीधे उपभोक्ताओं पर पड़ेगा.

(३) मीडिया पर सरकारी तंत्र हावी रहेगा. इसके दो प्रमुख कारण रहेंगे: पहला, विपक्ष की सरकार की आलोचना करने में कमजोरी; दूसरा, गैर-सरकारी स्रोतों से आय के अभाव में सरकारी मदद पर छत्तीसगढ़ी मीडिया की बरकरार निर्भरता.
Read More (आगे और पढ़ें)......

Tuesday, February 03, 2009

Barack Obama: A Man For All Seasons

He Came From Nowhere
Barack Obama isn’t so much Black or even half-Black as he is a Mirror, on which a nation, once great but now in the throes of an unprecedented identity crisis, sees the reflection of its diverse, divergent desires. Until two years ago, he was a global non-entity; a name often confused with its (then) more familiar if somewhat notorious homonym, Osama (after the Al Qaeda leader, Mr. Bin Laden).

Yet it is precisely this fact- of his discreet, even dignified, obscurity- which paradoxically enough accounts for Mr. Obama’s meteoric metamorphosis as the world’s most recognizable, talked-about Face: ever an artful politician, he pulled off electoral history’s greatest coup by turning what appeared to be his most debilitating weakness into his greatest strength: capitalizing on his Obscurity, he suddenly became all things to all people.

His infinitely more famous rivals- Mrs. Clinton and Mr. McCain, to name two more unfortunate ones- simply didn’t have that sort of advantage. Having been in public life for decades- in Mr. McCain’s case, for almost as long as Mr. Obama’s earthly life- their every action and every utterance had been dissected, discussed, debated, deified and demonized to death; more to the point, most people had already formed their variegated Opinions of them and those that didn’t probably couldn’t care less. Mr. Obama- and his excellent campaign team- had the astuteness to make the most of this. He began by making those who didn’t- couldn’t- care, care.

Like Karl Rowe (George W. Bush’s wizard of a mentor), who based his protégé’s victories by tapping into America’s hitherto untapped and instinctually conservative exurbias, Mr. Obama’s team reached out to an entirely new demographic: the hitherto politically nonchalant but temperamentally liberal Generation Y; the sort of chaps who hang out at Starbuck’s and inhabit fast-mushrooming social networking websites like Facebook; the kind that are desperately looking for a Purpose, any purpose. Mr. Obama gave them a Purpose: he- Mr. Obama- was it.

And The Money Kept Rollin’ In
Mrs. Clinton and Mr. McCain meanwhile were busily wooing the Establishment with its tempting $2500-a-plate fund-raisers. In retrospect, that wasn’t very clever: America, after all, is a land that thrives on Las Vegas, and Vegas is a place that thrives on slot-machines, which account for more than 70% of its takings, and not on high-rollers (who in any case prefer to head for Monte Carlo and now increasingly to Macau). That, I guess, is the Cardinal Rule of how the world works: Ignore the little people who persistently, patiently put coins into insatiable slots, and you’ve no business left; get the slot-machines ringing, and the high-rollers follow. In the Gamble that is Politics, Mr. Obama went straight to the slot-machines, and- there’s no better way to put this- he hit the jackpot, big-time.

Every time he needed money- and rest assured, he needed loads of it to establish a campaign machine to rival that of the formidable Clintonistas as well as the GOP’s (Grand Old Party is how the Republican Party is more commonly known)- he simply went to the tens of millions of mostly youthful members logged on to his webpage on Facebook, and lo and behold, the money kept rolling in: by donating a few dollars each, they suddenly found involvement, purpose and hope; and the trickle of online dollars almost magically transformed itself into a flood of several millions. But that wasn’t all: Mr. Obama also ensured that their participation didn’t end with the dollar; like some post-modern Messiah, he urged his minions to go out, commune at homely gatherings, and spread the Word deploying the very latest media modern technology has to offer.

John 1:1
And that brings me to the single most important aspect of Mr. Obama’s campaign: before everything else- even before the untapped demographic and the money- there was the Word, which set everything in motion. Actually, there were Two Words. Change and Hope, Hope and Change. At first, they sound awfully clichéd. We’ve heard politicians of all persuasions utter them countless times before; their etymology is primordial, buried deep into our species’ collective unconscious as a palliative to fear and fossilization. Yet, when Mr. Obama uttered them- and this wasn’t a very uncommon occurrence, to say the least- it struck a cord in those mysterious places that set butterflies magically aflutter in our bellies.

Poetry aside, it is important, I think, to understand just why that happened. Here, we must perforce employ the tools bequeathed to us by Jacques Derrida and examine three things: what was said and why (content and context); who said it (author); and what was meant and how the meaning thereof was perceived by those who heard it (or to use Quentin Skinner’s terminology, the ‘intended illocutionary force’).

Osama begat Obama
To first understand the significance of the content, we must necessarily look to the context. This was provided most obviously by the Bush Years, marked as they were by a spiraling descent into war, penury and global ridicule. This was an era (hopefully now ending) permeated by what I’ve elsewhere called Osama-phobia after the chief cause- the sine qua non- of President Bush’s abject but involuntary reversal from his first campaign’s big-on-morals-and-small-on-government stance. Fear, or more precisely, the fear of Fear, fed into- and authored- every decision he took. (His Vice President, the much more hated and aloof Dick Cheney, didn’t do anything to assuage these fears.) The two parameters of American Supremacy alluded to by Henry Kissinger in his monumental treatise on Diplomacy- military might and economic prowess- were both put to severe test by the quagmire of the double-invasions of Afghanistan & Iraq, and a widening and ultimately insurmountable Deficit- the typically American habit of spending more than they earn- that has brought about a global recession.

In the memorable words of the Eagle’s song, Iraq, in effect, became Mr. Bush’s Hotel California: You can checkout any time you like, But you can never leave! Despite his rather premature “Mission Accomplished” glee, the war in Iraq procrastinated indefinitely. From the start, the Invasion of Iraq was doomed: his justification for the invasion- that Saddam Hussein, the then Tirkiti despot of Iraq, possessed weapons of mass destruction (WMD), which he hoped perhaps to use against America in league with Al Qaeda- turned out to be, to put it mildly, untrue; his method of conducting that invasion- against the express wishes of the international community- ended up alienating even America’s closest friends (with the notable exception of Britain’s Tony Blair, who inturn ended up losing his own chair); and his hope that the invasion would somehow usher in an era of democracy in the Middle East wasn’t quite realized to the extent that he had expected.

In the Case of Jefferson v Hamilton
But despite all this, Mr. Bush’s worst enemy wasn’t Osama bin Laden, the Taliban or even Saddam Hussein: it was the American People themselves. No wartime American President with the possible exception of Franklin Delano Roosevelt has for long enjoyed his fellow-citizens’- and the Congress’- unflinching support: despite their rather militaristic national anthem, Americans have never been comfortable with the sight of body-bags of slain soldiers wrapped in star-spangled banners arriving home. At heart, they remain Jeffersonians (after Thomas Jefferson), content to be an island (albeit a rather large one!) blissfully unaware of what’s happening beyond their shores and hoping that they wouldn’t need a government to govern them at all. Let us not forget that when Mr. Bush first emerged on the scene, he too was something of a Jeffersonian in the ideals he so passionately espoused.

But he too, like most Americans, was confronted with a distinctly Hamiltonian reality (after Alexander Hamilton): the almost instinctual need of the American Establishment- Noam Chomsky’s military-industrial complex- to look for new enemies when old ones are gone, as epitomized in the ironically self-fulfilling prophecy of Samuel Huntington’s Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of the New World Order. In this sense atleast, Huntington gave a fresh, new lease of life to Hamilton. And what a lease that was! President Bush, the quintessential Jeffersonian, became a die-hard disciple of Hamilton in what was to be his life’s second epiphany (the first one took him from Booze to the Bible). Of course, it would be wrong to put all the blame on the Establishmentarian Inertia of Washington: Mr. Bin Laden, in all fairness, deserves much of the credit for Mr. Bush’s conversion.

His attack on the Twin Towers (9/11) only amplified Mr. Bush’s innate sense of Christian morality: his world was suddenly divided into black & white, good & the axis of evil, and under the circumstances, Crusade was the logical outcome of Jihad. Morality breeds decisiveness; lack of it makes one indecisive. This is America’s lesson gleaned from its last two Presidents, Mr. Bush and Mr. Clinton. I’ve often wondered what Mr. Clinton would’ve done had he been President on 9/11. Sure, he wouldn’t have invaded Iraq, WMDs or no WMDs (remember his dilly-dallying on Kosovo, Congo and the rest); he would certainly have ruled out going it alone, without the backing of the world community (God knows, Mr. Hussein counted on that!); he might not even have considered an outright invasion of Afghanistan, toying first with Diplomacy or being content with the destruction of Mr. Bin Laden’s person. But the question that begs to be answered is this: would Al Qaeda be as thoroughly destroyed as it is now; and would 9/11 have been the last terrorist attack on American soil?

As far as the Bush Legacy is concerned, I believe in two things: one, that it was Mr. Bush’s pandering to his Jeffersonian instincts that ultimately led to his failure in Iraq. He wanted to invade Iraq, destroy Saddam and get out as quickly as possible with a minimum of force and cost; the idea that nations don’t just build themselves after being invaded and destroyed didn’t quite cross his Jeffersonian mind (apparently he forgot all about post-second world war Western Europe and Japan, both of which required prolonged infusions of American money, manpower and foresight to rebuild themselves). The success of the Surge in Iraq- today’s provincial elections have brought true democracy to the Middle East for the first time in history, and Mr. Bush should be given due credit for it- shows that the middle-of-the-road approach is at fault. Had Mr. Bush not been bullied by public opinion and his own mindset to limit the costs to America in the first instance, his country wouldn’t have ended up spending so much- in terms of blood, sweat, toil and money- in Iraq, and thousands of innocent lives might’ve been saved. In short, if he is to be blamed, it should be for doing too little; not too much. Secondly, I also believe that it is too early to pronounce judgment on the Bush Legacy: History will have to wait for things to settle down in Iraq before arriving at any sort of decision; hopefully, it will look more kindly upon the Bush Years than our own generation. (To see what I mean, take a look at HBO's award-winning mini-series on John Adams, America's mostly-forgotten and much-misunderstood second President.)

No Specifics Please, We're American
But I’m getting ahead of myself: it is precisely from the as-yet-unsettled dust of the Bush Years that an obscure entity like Mr. Obama has emerged to take on the world; the Present, and not History, is responsible for that. Hope and Change- the Two Words- stand for everything the Bush Years did not; they are, in a way, the anti-thesis of everything those Years have come symbolize today. They’re also, interestingly enough, the Lowest Common Denominator (LCD)- that indescribable abstract- which binds together today’s America. Looking back at the rhetoric of his campaign- both before and after the Primaries- it appears that Mr. Obama said very little indeed: he said that things were bad and that change was needed (without elaborating on the how of it); he said that America needed to get out of Iraq soon (again, without letting us in on the how and when); he said that he was for the New (but not against the Old); he said that the poor deserved to be taken care of by the state and the rich didn’t have to be taxed needlessly to do that (not letting us in on the secret of just where he was going to get the money from to do that); and he said that there was Despair everywhere, and he was the Hope that would drive it away (again, not telling just how he hoped to do that). In short, he said Everything without saying Anything.

It was this artful avoidance of the pitfalls of getting into the specifics of things- something which his rivals simply couldn’t resist in their desire to show that they knew it all- that made Mr. Obama’s Words so appealing to so many not just in America but around the world. The Color of his skin also helped. In electing their first Black President, America belied its earlier Image as a Hypocritical Hegemon that systematically excluded its non-White population from everyday governance while pretending to be the very Beacon of Liberty. Till the very fag end of campaigning, my father, so used to this Image, believed in all sincerity that “they would never elect a Black man as President.” But they did precisely that- and in doing so, they busted the myth that President Lincoln even after waging war on his own people for the sake of ending slavery couldn’t. And who better than a President Obama- half-black, half-white, half-Muslim, half-Christian, half-African, all-American- to send out the Message that America has Changed; or to use Mr. Obama’s own historic words, “Change Has Come to America.”

A Napoleon in America?
Truth be told, after the nine angst-ridden years of Osama-phobia, America- and the world- has quite simply been swept off its feet by Obama-mania. Mr. Obama likes to compare himself with his illustrious forbearer, Abraham Lincoln. Like him, President Lincoln, who hadn’t won a single election before, was a relative non-entity amidst more celebrated personages such as Stephen Douglas; and like Mr. Obama, he owed his victory chiefly to his charismatic powers of oratory. But while his rise was most certainly unexpected, it was by no stretch of imagination heroic. (The heroism part was to come much later, when the outcome of the Civil War against the Confederacy became apparent.) It did not for instance signal the fruition of centuries of anti-racist struggle as Mr. Obama’s has done for many. Fear- and not Hope- marked President Lincoln’s first Inauguration.

In all probability, future-day historians would find more fascinating similarities between our Age and that of Napoleon after the 18th Brumaire: Bonaparte’s rise not only marked the ending of Jacobin Terreur- and momentarily, the Ancien Regime (which was to reassert itself one last time at the historic Vienna Congress of 1815)- but also ushered in an era of Hope throughout the Western World, prompting among others the composer Beethoven to compose & dedicate his majestically beautiful ‘Eroica’ symphony to ‘Napoleon Bonaparte, the Child of Revolution’.

It was only much later that the by-now completely deaf composer regretted his dedication: by then, the Child of Revolution had crowned himself Emperor, invaded much of Europe and installed his siblings as kings and queens: the Ancien Regime was back in full swing. I’m sure that President Obama would do nothing of the sort, and the comparison is totally undeserved. But then again, come to think of it, who could’ve thought that Mr. Bush would do the things he did?

After all, being all things to all people is no easy task. As Mr. Obama knows only too well, you inevitably end up disappointing someone: “One thing you can be sure of,” he told his fellow-diners at the Congress on the day of his Inauguration, “I will make mistakes.”

Let’s hope they are few and far in-between. America- and the world- can’t afford too many.

Godspeed, Mr. Obama!
Read More (आगे और पढ़ें)......

Comment: The Legacy of George W.

Note:The following is an excerpt from the article "Barack Obama: A Man for All Seasons". Given the latter's length, I felt that Mr. Bush at the very least deserves a separate post of his own.

Last thing I remember, I was
Running for the door
I had to find the passage back
To the place I was before
"Relax," said the night man,
We are programmed to receive.
You can checkout any time you like,
But you can never leave!
The Eagles, Hotel California

The Bush Years were marked by a spiraling descent into war, penury and global ridicule of U.S.A. This was an era (hopefully now ending) permeated by what might be called Osama-phobia after the chief cause- the sine qua non- of President Bush’s abject but admittedly involuntary reversal from his first campaign’s now somewhat archaic big-on-morals-and-small-on-government stance. Fear, or more precisely, the fear of Fear, fed into- and authored- every decision he took. (His Vice President, the much more vilified Dick Cheney, didn’t do anything to assuage these fears.)

The two parameters of American Supremacy alluded to by Henry Kissinger in his monumental treatise on Diplomacy- military might and economic prowess- were both put to severe test by the quagmire of the Afghanistan-Iraq double-invasion; Iraq, and a widening and ultimately insurmountable Deficit- the typically American habit of spending more than they earn- that has brought about a global recession. 



In the memorable words of the Eagle’s song, Iraq, in effect, became Mr. Bush’s Hotel California: You can checkout any time you like, But you can never leave! Despite his rather premature “Mission Accomplished” glee, the war in Iraq procrastinated indefinitely. From the start, the Invasion of Iraq was doomed: his justification for the invasion- that Saddam Hussein, the then Tirkiti despot of Iraq, possessed weapons of mass destruction (WMD), which he hoped perhaps to use against America in league with Al Qaeda- turned out to be, to put it mildly, untrue; his method of conducting that invasion- against the express wishes of the international community- ended up alienating even America’s closest friends (with the notable exception of Britain’s Tony Blair, who inturn ended up losing his own chair); and his hope that the invasion would somehow usher in an era of democracy in the Middle East wasn’t quite realized to the extent that he had expected.



In the Case of Jefferson v Hamilton

But despite all this, Mr. Bush’s worst enemy wasn’t Osama bin Laden, the Taliban or even Saddam Hussein: it was the American People themselves. No wartime American President with the possible exception of Franklin Delano Roosevelt has for long enjoyed his fellow-citizens’- and the Congress’- unflinching support: despite their rather militaristic national anthem, Americans have never been comfortable with the sight of body-bags of slain soldiers wrapped in star-spangled banners arriving home. At heart, they remain Jeffersonians (after Thomas Jefferson), content to be an island (albeit a rather large one!) blissfully unaware of what’s happening beyond their shores and hoping that they wouldn’t need a government to govern them at all. Let us not forget that when Mr. Bush first emerged on the scene, he too was something of a Jeffersonian in the ideals he so passionately espoused. 



But he too, like most Americans, was confronted with a distinctly Hamiltonian reality (after Alexander Hamilton): the almost instinctual need of the American Establishment- Noam Chomsky’s military-industrial complex- to look for new enemies when old ones are gone, as epitomized in the ironically self-fulfilling prophecy of Samuel Huntington’s Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of the New World Order. In this sense atleast, Huntington gave a fresh, new lease of life to Hamilton. And what a lease that was! President Bush, the quintessential Jeffersonian, became a die-hard disciple of Hamilton in what was to be his life’s second epiphany (the first one took him from Booze to the Bible). Of course, it would be wrong to put all the blame on the Establishmentarian Inertia of Washington: Mr. Bin Laden, in all fairness, deserves much of the credit for Mr. Bush’s conversion. 



His attack on the Twin Towers (9/11) only amplified Mr. Bush’s innate sense of Christian morality: his world was suddenly divided into black & white, good & the axis of evil, and under the circumstances, Crusade was the logical outcome of Jihad. Morality breeds decisiveness; lack of it makes one indecisive. This is America’s lesson gleaned from its last two Presidents, Mr. Bush and Mr. Clinton. I’ve often wondered what Mr. Clinton would’ve done had he been President on 9/11. Sure, he wouldn’t have invaded Iraq, WMDs or no WMDs (remember his dilly-dallying on Kosovo, Congo and the rest); he would certainly have ruled out going it alone, without the backing of the world community (God knows, Mr. Hussein counted on that!); he might not even have considered an outright invasion of Afghanistan, toying first with Diplomacy or being content with the destruction of Mr. Bin Laden’s person. But the question that begs to be answered is this: would Al Qaeda be as thoroughly destroyed as it is now; and would 9/11 have been the last terrorist attack on American soil? 



With respect to the Bush Years, I offer the following two observations: one, that it was Mr. Bush’s pandering to his Jeffersonian instincts that ultimately led to his failure in Iraq. He wanted to invade Iraq, destroy Saddam and get out as quickly as possible with a minimum of force and cost; the idea that nations don’t just build themselves after being invaded and destroyed didn’t quite cross his Jeffersonian mind (apparently he forgot all about post-second world war Western Europe and Japan, both of which required prolonged infusions of American money, manpower and foresight to rebuild themselves).

The success of the Surge in Iraq- today’s provincial elections have brought true democracy to the Middle East for the first time in history, and Mr. Bush should be given due credit for it- shows that the middle-of-the-road approach is at fault. Had Mr. Bush not been bullied by public opinion and his own mindset to limit the costs to America in the first instance, his country wouldn’t have ended up spending so much- in terms of blood, sweat, toil and money- in Iraq, and thousands of innocent lives might’ve been saved. In short, if he is to be blamed, it should be for doing too little; not too much.

Secondly, I believe it is too premature to pronounce judgment on the Bush Legacy: History will have to wait for things to settle down in Iraq before arriving at any sort of decision; hopefully, it would look more kindly upon the Bush Years than our own generation.

(To see what I mean, take a look at HBO's award-winning mini-series on John Adams, America's mostly-forgotten and much-misunderstood second President.)


Read More (आगे और पढ़ें)......

Saturday, November 29, 2008

ICH BIN EIN MUMBAIKAR

For three nights and two days now, a city- and a nation- have been held hostage: the precise identity and motive of the perpetrators remains uncertain; their methodology, however, is (regrettably) no longer in doubt: for the umpteenth time, hundreds of unarmed civilians- business travelers, restaurant goers, innocent bystanders, hotel guests & staff- have fallen victim to a meticulously-planned & carefully-coordinated cross-border terrorist attack in the heart of India’s financial capital, Mumbai.

Most significantly, it has exposed the weak underbelly- the absolute vulnerability- of our nation’s security apparatus.

A Different Class of Attacks
The Attack on Mumbai is being televised nonstop. As a blogger, I shall attempt here to put what we are seeing in perspective. 



First: the Victims of the Attacks. This isn’t for the first time that the world's Maximum City has come under fire: at least two bomb blasts- one at the Stock Exchange and another on Mumbai’s local trains- have resulted in an equal, if not more, number of deaths. What makes this particular set of attacks different- apart of course from its inherent Drama (to which I shall come to later)- are its Victims, or more precisely, the class of its Victims. Those killed earlier were, to put it blatantly, commoners in an extraordinary situation: the sort of people who live in faraway suburbs and commute in second-class local trains; not exactly the sort who would put up in USD 250 a night suite, or spend an average monthly wage on fine dining at Tiffin, a trendy new restaurant at The Oberoi that was witness to a veritable bloodbath on the night of the attacks.

In this case, the victims are not-quite-common people caught up in what is alarmingly becoming an only too common situation. A lot of the people who were taken hostage & killed during the past forty-eight hours belonged to the so-called Class of Untouchables: those who we- and by we, I mean our Collective Imagination- thought were above, among other things, being attacked by terrorists; the glass-housed Glitterati, so to speak. Now: the glass is broken & we realize- much to our discomfort- that even these hallowed creatures aren’t safe & truth be told, this terrifies us more than any of the previous attacks.

Secondly: the Media’s Role in taking the high-voltage Drama- rapid rounds of crossfire between policemen and terrorists ensconced in sushi-bars, masked commandos descending on rooftops from helicopters, guests waving for help from behind glass windows of their twenty-first floor suites, grenade launchers & AK-47s, bodies of brave warriors wrapped in tricolors, relieved evacuees- into every Indian household with a television set, has, for better & worse, made every Indian- both in India & abroad- a direct participant in the unfolding tragedy. Suddenly, every other news, including the death of a former prime minister, is no longer news. Suddenly, we’re all- you & I- Victims under siege, whether we’re in Mumbai or not. Our feeling of helplessness is- has become- universal: no one is- can be- safe. On the positive side, this creates in us- a largely divided nation- a sense of ‘Unity in Fear’: suddenly, each one of us is saying “Ich Bin Ein Mumbaikar.”

Thirdly: on the flip side, this pervasive sense of Paranoia creates in all of us, an overwhelming need to blame someone, anyone. And the easiest scapegoat: Politicians, of course. It is no secret that the Union Home Minister- and by implication, the Government of India- already suffers from something of a credibility crisis: he was widely ridiculed for reportedly having changed his dress thrice within an hour’s span of Delhi being bombed some months ago; his defense, that this ‘serial-dressing’ wasn’t exactly a vice, did little to assuage a slightly misplaced comparison with a certain Nero, who allegedly played the flute while Rome burned. Apparently, this metaphor has been extended to incorporate all politicians as a species. “Keep Out”, “Get Lost”: these are the overwhelming messages to them. It is they who’ve in the public imagination failed to protect us as a nation. Even worse, we feel they would only be too eager to use this Tragedy for political capital. A case in point is the Gujarat chief minister, Narendra Modi’s sudden- and thoroughly unproductive- appearance before The Oberoi this afternoon.

In my opinion, this last aspect merits further discussion.

They Shoot Politicians, Don’t They
For the terrorists- the wannabe fidayeen- the prospect of the Attacks might well have looked like a brochure for a perfect vacation: a Cruise across the quiet blue waters of the Arabian Sea followed by two days & nights of Massacre at a plush Mumbai hotel. Breakfast included & Jannat guaranteed. Bad joke aside, it is precisely this- the ease with which they did it all- that disturbs me most. It is almost as if we- to be more precise, the Awesome Might of the Indian state- put up absolutely no resistance at all. We might just as well have extended them an Invitation.

Less than forty hours into the Attacks, the GOI admitted that it wasn’t equipped to guard its coastline: forty terrorists, armed to the hilt with AK-47s, RDX, hand-grenades & satellite phones, had snuck undetected aboard stolen fishing boats into India’s financial capital without the Marine Police, the Coast Guard or the Customs getting wind of things. Yet: this is merely symptomatic of a massive & deep-rooted Intelligence failure. The different agencies involved in the intelligence business- not just those in India but across the world- simply failed to connect the dots in real-time before it was too late: a stolen boat in Gujarat; six missing fishermen, one of who was later found dead; hi-tech jihadi recruitment & training centers brazenly operating out of Faridkot; calls made to the (erstwhile) L-e-T network in Karachi from satellite phones; sightings of suspicious-looking dinghies by fishermen off the coast of Mumbai.

Intelligence, after all, is more an Art- and less a Science- of stopping things before they happen. By its very nature, therefore, Intelligence cannot be foolproof. We, as a nation, must be prepared to face further possibilities of such failures.

What happened in Mumbai- what is happening in Mumbai even now- has the appearance of an effective but also, a painfully improvised, response to a particular challenge: for the first time in Independent India’s history, the nation’s security forces involving the NSG, the Mumbai Police, Maharashtra’s ATS (Anti-terrorist Squad), the Army, Navy and the Airforce put up a unified response in the face of a sustained, highly coordinated attack carried out from at least three well-supplied ‘control rooms’ in the heart of Mumbai’s commercial-administrative district lasting no less than forty-eight hours (and still not showing signs of ending).

There are important lessons to be learnt from this. More than anything else, the manner in which the situation in Mumbai is being ‘contained’ gives us reason for Hope: we aren’t as ill-prepared as we had feared; indeed, our security forces have shown remarkable fortitude in the face of terrifying calamities.

The politicians, if simply because they’ve let them (the forces) do their job without becoming too much of a nuisance, deserve a second chance to get their act in order & not, mind you, for milking this Tragedy for political mileage.

AJ
Read More (आगे और पढ़ें)......

get the latest posts in your email. ताज़े पोस्ट अब अपने ई-मेल पर सीधे पढ़ें

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

DISCLAIMER. आवश्यक सूचना

1. No part of this Blog shall be published and/or transmitted, wholly or in part, without the prior permission of the author, and/or without duly recognizing him as such. (१. इस ब्लॉग का कोई भी भाग, पूरा या अधूरा, बिना लेखक की पूर्व सहमति के, किसी भी प्रकार से प्रसारित या प्रकाशित नहीं किया जा सकता.)
2. This Blog subscribes to a Zero Censorship Policy: no comment on this Blog shall be deleted under any circumstances by the author. (२. ये ब्लॉग जीरो सेंसरशिप की नीति में आस्था रखता है: किसी भी परिस्थिति में कोई भी टिप्पणी/राय ब्लॉग से लेखक द्वारा हटाई नहीं जायेगी.)
3. The views appearing on this Blog are the author's own, and do not reflect, in any manner, the views of those associated with him. (३. इस ब्लॉग पर दर्शित नज़रिया लेखक का ख़ुद का है, और किसी भी प्रकार से, उस से सम्बंधित व्यक्तियों या संस्थाओं के नज़रिए को नहीं दर्शाता है.)

CONTACT ME. मुझसे संपर्क करें

Amit Aishwarya Jogi
Anugrah, Civil Lines
Raipur- 492001
Chhattisgarh, INDIA
Telephone/ Fascimile: +91 771 4068703
Mobile: +91 942420 2648 (AMIT)
email: amitaishwaryajogi@gmail.com
Skype: jogi.amit
Yahoo!: amitjogi2001